Tribalism Ascendant

     I’ve written about tribalism on several occasions, mainly at Liberty’s Torch V1.0. Because of associations that link tribe with race, it’s a subject that induces considerable trepidation in persons who dislike being called nasty names. Yet it’s a real phenomenon, it has deleterious effects on a society, and when allowed any latitude it can bring about actual civil warfare.

     Here are the key snippets of that earlier essay:

     A tribe is a group with certain social and political characteristics:

  1. It possesses a set of criteria for determining who is (and who is not) a member;
  2. It demonstrates a substantial degree of cohesion over time;
  3. It prefers members to non-members in significant ways;
  4. It enforces a code of conduct upon members, whether formally or informally;
  5. It regards interaction and interpenetration with outsiders as occasions of elevated danger and opportunity.

     Even after nation-states have formalized their legal systems and all that goes with them, whatever tribes they have subsumed will still exhibit tribal characteristics, at least for a while. In particular, members of a subsumed tribe will continue to prefer one another to the members of other subsumed tribes. In historical studies, this is often called sectionalism, but the geographical connotations of that word should not be allowed to lead us astray. After subsumption by a nation-state, the members of a tribe will often undergo some degree of internal dispersion. Yet they will continue to maintain tribal preferences as they disperse, until interpenetration and the slow process of binding to their new locales have had time to weaken them. Consider the resistance of various religious groups to exogamy as an illustration.

     Should political incentives arise that reinforce tribal distinctions and preferences, havoc will ensue. A nation-state cannot endure under conditions of internal inter-tribal strife; as Abraham Lincoln put it, a house divided cannot stand. There must ultimately be either a convulsive reduction of the tribes to political passivity, for example by warfare, or a parting of the ways that dissolves the nation-state into two or more separate units, as happened after the British relinquished the rule of India.

     Let that passage sink in for a few moments before continuing on.


     Consider the following three news stories:

     The killers in the above stories are all Negroes. In each case, the media’s determination to perpetuate the “American blacks are oppressed” narrative is operating to spare the killers the appropriate attention and judicial treatment. Were white perpetrators to commit acts even remotely similar to the ones chronicled in those stories, their treatment would be radically different…especially if their victims were black.

     I shan’t light off on another Cui bono rant about such journalistic malfeasance. But what does it say about the media’s collective fear of the American Negro tribe? Would any other demographic in the United States receive equal forbearance from the fourth estate? Would any racial, ethnic, religious, or political cohort be treated with such kid gloves?

     The American Negro tribe has established itself as one to be feared. For nearly two years, its members have rioted, vandalized, looted, and committed crimes of violence without let or hindrance. Urban police forces have stood aside and let them do so. Cities with appreciable black population fractions that have not suffered such chaos are few. When a black American has met his demise at the hands of a white American, the media have treated the event as a modern-day lynching.

     These are the fruits of tribalism ascendant. While I can’t predict its course, I’m certain that other demographic cohorts are viewing the black tribe’s seeming immunity to correction and asking themselves, “How can we get in on this?” Success does attract emulators, after all.


     In another essay, I wrote:

     When a society makes special provisions for a particular class of persons, such that those persons have a good expectation of not suffering for illegal or antisocial behavior, it has committed the worst imaginable injustice against the persons in that class who honor their society’s laws and norms: it has equalized the legal, social, and moral positions of good citizens and thugs. Thus, if ninety percent of such a class is law-abiding and decorous while ten percent is violent, dishonest, or disruptive, the latter category will come to overshadow the former in the perceptions of persons outside the class — not because ten percent is a majority, but because that anti-social subgroup is identified with the class’s special set of privileges.

     That shift in perception has taken place among Americans, whether or not they’re willing to say so. Whatever the actual proportions may be, a majority of American whites have come to view American blacks as dangerous to them. They are not wrong, though to say so where others can hear, as for example John Derbyshire has done, is to take a huge chance with one’s social and economic position. Nor does it lessen one’s vulnerability to have irrefutable evidence for one’s contentions.


     I could go on, but I’d mainly be repeating things I’ve written on previous occasions. In closing, I’d like to present a snippet from a great book, a book that every American should read upon attaining his majority: the late Clarence Carson’s The American Tradition. This comes at the conclusion of his chapter “Of the Civilizing of Groups:”

     [M]uch of the practical empowering of groups has not been accomplished by either constitutional amendment or legislative act. Instead, in many instances law enforcement officers have looked the other way while unions employed coercion and violence. Politicians have practiced a policy of divide and conquer on the American people. The Democratic Party has been most adept at this, though the Republicans have often attempted to compete. They [the Democrats] have forged a party out of numerous minority groups, making promises and presumably providing favors for them. Many of these groups have become vested interests, legally and extra-legally.
     Since the above was written, the disorders have intensified and spread. Most recently, they have been extended to colleges, courtrooms, and in the streets surrounding political conventions. The pattern is repeating itself. The birds are coming home to roost. If the restraints are removed from group behavior by the grant of special privilege, if groups are empowered by law, if direct action is advanced because the end is “good,” if the means for civilizing of groups are abandoned, compulsion and authoritarianism must be used to preserve order….
     When groups become accustomed to having others submit to threats and pressure, they will become less and less willing to brook resistance. But there comes a time when social order requires resistance to the anarchy of contending groups. The road of resistance, however, leads to despotism in one form or another.

     Professor Carson wrote that in 1964. Where he says “groups,” I say “tribes,” but the import is unchanged. Draw the moral.


Skip to comment form

    • Hoagie on December 22, 2021 at 1:04 PM

    The barbarity, destruction and racism now propelling the black tribe in America was fostered by the “progressives” and it is done as a feature not a glitch.   The end run are tanks and our own military in our streets to subdue the violent whites who refuse to kneel when the Black National Anthem is played.


    Next they’ll come for our guns then impose a “Reparation Tax” on all whites.    Then the real killing starts.

  1. The other groups don’t like blacks at all but they collectively hate White people more so for now it is a marriage of convenience. When it stops being convenient and they turn on each other? Best to be out of the blast radius.

      • Zorost on December 23, 2021 at 10:11 AM

      They won’t turn on each other until after we are gone, which is why those in charge are focusing them on us first. And at that point I’m sure the Left has something else planned, like a hardcore crackdown. As Yuri Bezmenov would call it, “the normalization phase.”

    • Martin on December 22, 2021 at 10:54 PM

    Thank you for your insight.  We have a serious problem on our hands with the tribalism that started with Barack Obama. I was in the Army from 5/01 to 5/05 and there was no emphasis on race; we were all American’s united in vengeance against radical Islam. Division did not start in this country until Obama came to power and put into play the marxist playbook creation of a “boogey man” to focus blame and hate on. That boogey man was the White, Christian male.   Things have gone too far with the Hollywood, the media, academia and our politicians all on the same corrupt side.  I for one look forward to have the opportunity to fight to reclaim this county that has given me so much.  God bless you sir and Merry Christmas to you and your.

      • Zorost on December 23, 2021 at 10:13 AM

      There has been a problem with racial tribes in this nation for a long time. Blacks since the 1960’s, the tribe that released the blacks on us for much longer than that.

      The marxist playbook in America goes back at least to the Frankfurt school in the 1930s.

    • SteveF on December 23, 2021 at 9:11 AM

    Would any other demographic in the United States receive equal forbearance from the fourth estate? Would any racial, ethnic, religious, or political cohort be treated with such kid gloves?

    Government employees come immediately to mind.

    For the record, I do not think that all government employees are lazy, incompetent, or actively corrupt. The system does a mighty fine job of protecting those who are, though.

    • Hoagie on December 23, 2021 at 9:53 AM

    I can’t currently postulate the percentage of blacks and/or black families currently on the dole in the U.S. but I would submit it would approach 99% if not for “government” jobs at all levels.

    • Zorost on December 23, 2021 at 10:16 AM

    Everyone else has tribed up, it’s about time Whites did too.  We are behind the power curve, and it’s just about the End Game.

Comments have been disabled.