How Much Worse Could It Get?

     In reflecting on the piece below, it struck me that today’s federal government has become so thoroughly corrupt – so anti-American — that I’d be hard pressed to name a government anywhere or anywhen that compares unfavorably to it. And as usual when I’m only half awake, that started a fresh train of half-facetious thought.

     Many years ago, William F. Buckley stated pungently that he’d rather be governed by the first two thousand people in the Boston phone book than by the faculty of Harvard University. He, too, was probably being a bit facetious, but it’s still an approach that deserves some thought. What if the elections that currently populate the two Houses of Congress were scrapped in favor of the following biennial procedure:

  1. On “Selection Day,” tokens representing all the zip codes in the United States are put into a Bingo-style randomizing drum.
  2. The drum is spun briskly, and – under the watchful attention of an auditor from Price Waterhouse, of course – a zip code is selected.
  3. The names of all the persons in that zip code who are Constitutionally eligible to occupy seats in the House of Representatives are put into the drum.
  4. The drum is once again spun briskly, and 435 names are selected. These become our Representatives for the two years to come.
  5. The zip code tokens are returned to the drum, it’s spun once again, and a second zip code is selected.
  6. The names of all the persons in that zip code who are Constitutionally eligible to occupy seats in the Senate are put into the drum.
  7. Yet another spin, and 100 names are selected. These become our Senators for the two years to come.

     Do you think it would work any better or worse than our current system of selling Congressional offices to the highest bidder?

6 comments

Skip to comment form

  1. it struck me that today’s federal government has become so thoroughly corrupt

    Something in the ether this morning Fran?

    (Though recent history [suggests] strange women lying in ponds distributing swords look better as the basis for a system of government . . . .)Glenn Reynolds

    • Bob on December 21, 2023 at 8:55 AM

    I don’t know how, but the DumbocRATs would figure out some way to cheat the  process.

    1. (chuckle) Well, it’s a lead-pipe cinch that they would try, anyway.

    • Drumwaster on December 21, 2023 at 3:13 PM

    The only downside would be the fact that there is a non-trivial percentage of ZIP codes in the US (mostly scattered across the Mountainous and desert West) that don’t have 435 people, never mind 435 citizens capable of meeting the minimum age and residency standards. There are 41,704 from which to choose, and there are literally hundreds of ZIP codes with less than 435 total population.

    1. Well, okay, but I think we could make some allowances! 😁

    • TRX on December 22, 2023 at 1:24 PM

    My solution is the Powerball System.

    Every citizen of the USA has a Social Security Number.  They’ve been assigning them shortly after birth for quite some time now, and you have to have them for school, medical care, etc.

    Run the Powerball until a valid SSN pops up.  If they’re at or over the legal minimum age to hold the office, then that’s your next President, Senator, Congressman, justice of the peace, whatever.

    People often object with things like, “what if they’re criminals or senile?”

    My response is, “how would that differ from the people holding office now?”

    It probably wouldn’t be the “best” group of politicians… but it would certainly be a *representative* group of politicians.  The incumbents claim to govern as our representatives, not our masters, so they could hardly object.

     

     

Comments have been disabled.